How well are we doing?
2012 gold price - Predictions
**Silver Prices Now Added Below**
The Mineweb gold price competition is now closed and readers have come up with their verdict - and the average price predicted for the year is very close to that of a number of top banks. [We have constructed a sortable Excel Worksheet for Mineweb's table below & added a Bullish Ranking category. If you wish a copy please ask us: bilrum @ knology (dot) net]
Author: Lawrence Williams
Posted: Monday , 23 Jan 2012
Author: Lawrence Williams
Posted: Monday , 23 Jan 2012
LONDON -
We have had 101 entries for this year's Mineweb gold price competition and the full listing of these is set out in the table at the foot of this article. As can be seen in general readers are expecting gold to hit new highs during the year but perhaps not managing as high a year-end price as the forecast peak might suggest.
To an extent one suspects that many of the predictions represent wishful thinking by gold investors, although if this is the case such thinking could, in all but a couple of cases, be considered pretty muted, although there is a marked consistency in expectations of a $2,000 figure being breached at some stage during the year with 78% of entrants predicting this to occur. Mineweb readers as a whole have tended to be bullish on the gold price in the past, but, in the event their annual averages have tended to be not far off the mark and just as accurate, if not more so than the professional gold analyst entrants to the similar London Bullion Market Association competition each year. For the record the relevant LBMA competition figures for this year are High: $2055, Low: $1433, Average: $1766 - they are not asked for a year-end figure.
Interestingly too, the predictions from many of the entries in both our own and the LBMA competitions suggests entrants may be looking for a repeat of the 2011 price pattern with the gold price surging to new highs during the year before falling back sharply before the year end. This is actually counter to the trend of most prior years when the gold price peaks have been much later in the year, while weakness has mostly been seen in the summer.
Overall though the average gold price forecast for the year by readers is remarkably similar to the early year predictions of a number of top banks who mostly seem to be coming out in the high $1700 - low $1800 range for the year's average gold price - and the banks are not exactly known for over bullish forecasting.
We do not think that the general price trends expected by entrants are particularly surprising given the state of the global economy. China remains a price driver with continuing advertising pressures being put on its citizens to buy gold in campaigns by the big (state-controlled) banks while all the while there is the strong assumption that the Chinese government is adding surreptitiously to its own reserves which had been seen as very small in relation to the country's economy. This does tend to underpin the price to an extent with falls in the West during the day often countered overnight in the eastern markets.
However, the U.S. remains the world's biggest economy and any perceived recovery there does tend to have a negative impact on gold buying sentiment - as does any sign of dollar ‘strength', although the latter is somewhat spurious given the American debt situation which just means the dollar is perhaps weakening less fast than the other currencies against which the dollar index is measured. The green shoots of recovery in the U.S. economy too may be partly due to temporary fiscal stimuli, some of which were heavily reduced at the beginning of 2012 so it remains to be seen whether some of the gains by U.S. industry will continue as strongly this year.
The overall U.S. debt situation continues to be a worry for long term investors, many of whom still see gold as the ultimate safe haven, as of course does the European debt crisis which is currently in the spotlight, and will continue to remain so as feverish attempts are made to maintain the common currency within those 17 nations which subscribe to this - the Eurozone. The likelihood of a break up of this remains strong with both Greek and Portuguese debt currently rated at ‘junk' status, and some much bigger economies - notably Italy and Spain - near the brink. No-one really knows the full ramifications of a default by any of these countries on the hugely interconnected global banking sector, but if it occurs the fallout could be pretty horrific - perhaps far worse than the Lehmann collapse which battered the markets in 2008.
But it is not just the Eurozone countries which are at risk. The U.K. too, although making perhaps a more concerted effort to roll back its debt (so far unsuccessfully) is a major world economy which is also at serious risk. It does, unlike the individual Eurozone nations, but like the U.S., have the facility to print its own money and ultimately perhaps inflate its way towards mitigating its debt problems through devaluation of its currency, but the Eurozone imbroglio is making this more and more difficult with Europe being the U.K.'s major market and a downturn there impacting adversely on Britain's exports. Already nine European nations have been downgraded by at least one of the major ratings agencies and it may not be long before others suffer the same fate, as could even Japan. A Greek or Portuguese default could accelerate this process.
As noted above China has been the main driver of the global economy in the past few years with huge growth (by Western standards) but there are fears that this growth could be slowing as the country's export-driven economy (buoyed by a heavily controlled exchange rate) cannot be but adversely affected by the austerity programmes being put in place in the West. True its domestic economy is growing by leaps and bounds, but it could still take time before this can grow fast enough to counter the downturns elsewhere.
Gold should be a beneficiary in all the global uncertainty, but this does not necessarily mean there won't be setbacks in the progress of the price. As was seen in 2008, gold can fall back sharply as a struggle for liquidity in the face of bank collapses means good assets are sold along with bad. But as in late 2008/early 2009 gold may well bounce back far faster than other assets so the big money is likely to remain invested in gold as a possible wealth preserver.
In the U.S., election rhetoric from the more hard-money Republican Presidential candidates may also help raise gold's profile, so this could be another factor which could benefit the price overall.
So, be prepared for a bumpy ride in gold in the current year, and perhaps for several more years to come until some realistic end to the global financial crisis is seen. Overall one would expect the price trend to remain upwards but as the Mineweb reader, and other, predictions suggest there could be some sharp falls along the way.
Table: Entries for the 2012 Mineweb gold price competition.
Name or Nickname High Low Year end Average
007robo |
2150
|
1575
|
1855
|
1788
|
Aaron Vederoff |
1989
|
1478
|
1946
|
1743
|
ALLGOLD |
2400
|
1520
|
2100
|
1700
|
Alvaro Velasco |
2175
|
1150
|
1320
|
1662
|
Andy Palan |
2050
|
1550
|
1900
|
1750
|
apcklapka |
2367
|
1607
|
2235
|
1998
|
Arrien Westhuis |
2200
|
1495
|
2110
|
1895
|
Baron |
2478
|
1578
|
2267
|
1988
|
Barry |
1939
|
1549
|
1879
|
1780
|
Bill Rook |
1885
|
1530
|
1720
|
1670
|
Bill Rummel |
2180
|
1590
|
1834
|
1750
|
Bob Butalia |
2128
|
1454
|
1973
|
1641
|
Bradley Vooren |
2217
|
1517
|
1958
|
1718
|
Brimstone |
2034
|
1534
|
1875
|
1734
|
Broncel |
1910
|
1515
|
1712
|
1714
|
CIGA Doc |
2512
|
1568
|
2246
|
2063
|
Clint O'Bullion |
2115
|
1490
|
1890
|
1815
|
Colin Porter |
2215
|
1589
|
2115
|
1990
|
Craig Stockill |
1840
|
1080
|
1200
|
1640
|
David Fell |
2460
|
1486
|
2360
|
1950
|
David Tretbar |
2122
|
1371
|
1782
|
1674
|
Dennis |
2412
|
1598
|
2274
|
1936
|
Dick Leonard |
2700
|
1700
|
2700
|
2200
|
Divad |
2020
|
1580
|
1810
|
1740
|
Doug Silver |
1700
|
1300
|
1300
|
1550
|
Douglas Cundey |
4210
|
1550
|
3700
|
2560
|
DR KOK |
1850
|
1500
|
1700
|
1675
|
egarf |
2131
|
1598
|
1996
|
1901
|
Erik Highwind |
2777
|
1444
|
2333
|
1999
|
Euan Worthington |
2237
|
1429
|
1673
|
1735
|
Fazuza |
2145
|
1350
|
2145
|
1755
|
fitmike |
2227
|
1478
|
2156
|
1843
|
Frank |
2924
|
1599
|
2924
|
2261
|
FreeLance |
2414
|
1570
|
2265
|
1980
|
FUBAR |
2116
|
1365
|
2076
|
1748
|
G-Vision |
2030
|
1536
|
1990
|
1779
|
Geoff Candy |
2019
|
1460
|
1573
|
1840
|
Gold Bull |
2212
|
1486
|
1812
|
1793
|
Gold Stock Bull |
2350
|
1400
|
2200
|
1950
|
GoldenSing |
2250
|
1522
|
2050
|
1700
|
Gorm |
2875
|
1605
|
2388
|
1995
|
Graham Smith |
2089
|
1525
|
1872
|
1710
|
graybeard063 |
2520
|
1598
|
2160
|
2010
|
GUY SMILEY |
2398
|
1522
|
2222
|
1806
|
H.J. Clifford |
1964
|
1574
|
1791
|
1822
|
Herb Duerr |
2120
|
1430
|
1947
|
1778
|
Hilton Tarrant |
1944
|
1765
|
1836
|
1854
|
Jerry |
2450
|
1550
|
2000
|
1900
|
Jon Darcey |
2223
|
1506
|
2103
|
1776
|
Jonathan Bell |
1957
|
1547
|
1654
|
1682
|
Lawrence Williams |
1985
|
1590
|
1875
|
1778
|
LOOKOUT |
2400
|
1540
|
2100
|
1910
|
Maguana 6 |
1990
|
1500
|
1800
|
1758
|
Malcolm Hutton |
2122
|
1611
|
1839
|
1839
|
Marcocruces |
2375
|
1600
|
2250
|
2075
|
Maria Steyn |
1985
|
1412
|
1638
|
1548
|
markk |
2050
|
1400
|
1750
|
1830
|
Martin M |
2125
|
1450
|
1950
|
1835
|
Matt |
2100
|
1566
|
1925
|
1825
|
Matthew Grainger |
2075
|
1275
|
1955
|
1750
|
Mike Booton |
2115
|
1585
|
1720
|
1786
|
Mike Riegelman |
2552
|
1520
|
2309
|
2062
|
Mluzar |
2520
|
1595
|
2297
|
2089
|
Morne Kotze |
1996
|
1589
|
1845
|
1745
|
mwhof |
2013
|
1567
|
1877
|
1845
|
Neil Robinson |
2113
|
1430
|
2038
|
1895
|
Nic Wilson |
2045
|
1615
|
1924
|
1723
|
Obewon86 |
2241
|
1435
|
1849
|
1790
|
Ocnus |
2013
|
1646
|
1996
|
1826
|
Palladium is safer |
2040
|
1560
|
1995
|
1900
|
Pat Willis |
2101
|
1520
|
1820
|
1810
|
Peter Weiss |
1857
|
1412
|
1534
|
1670
|
petscho |
2441
|
1486
|
1946
|
1921
|
Phil |
2400
|
1500
|
2400
|
1800
|
Phillip Swanepoel |
2280
|
1598
|
2130
|
1880
|
R. Christian |
2148
|
1442
|
1890
|
1768
|
Richard M Palmer |
2518
|
1590
|
2485
|
2075
|
Robert Blair |
2120
|
1590
|
1920
|
1890
|
Robert Schafer |
2312
|
1496
|
2198
|
1876
|
Robert Wallace |
2250
|
1475
|
2010
|
1860
|
Ron Wimmer |
2048
|
1590
|
1811
|
1730
|
Ross Norman |
2100
|
1590
|
1940
|
1765
|
Ryan Bogenschneider |
2122
|
1490
|
1876
|
1837
|
S.E. Hayden |
2023
|
1520
|
1823
|
1738
|
Skagit Bob |
2137
|
1373
|
1973
|
1873
|
Socrates |
1906
|
1482
|
1794
|
1772
|
Stephen R Merriman |
2430
|
1580
|
2300
|
1970
|
straightsix |
2810
|
1560
|
2620
|
2010
|
Sunil Kumar Gupta |
1785
|
1150
|
1550
|
1500
|
T. Kelly |
1975
|
1450
|
1600
|
1750
|
Tazio 2012 |
2300
|
1550
|
2150
|
2050
|
Tim Dudley |
2155
|
1566
|
2075
|
1850
|
Timot 78 |
2200
|
1430
|
2050
|
1891
|
Tom Hartanto Soendoro |
1910
|
1100
|
1600
|
1605
|
Tony Low-Beer |
1705
|
1195
|
1425
|
1485
|
Vern Rampton |
2375
|
1590
|
2360
|
2115
|
Victor Gapare |
2020
|
1300
|
1800
|
1600
|
William C Lee |
2500
|
2000
|
2200
|
2200
|
Wilze |
1880
|
1404
|
1735
|
1630
|
www.gold-invest.co.uk |
1680
|
980
|
980
|
1350
|
Zee |
2453
|
1598
|
2250
|
2025
|
Averages |
2202.24
|
1499.1
|
1981.2
|
1832.3
|
Here's how we compare in both Gold and Silver with the "experts" - BANKERS!
Silver Hi: $50.00 Lo: $20.00 Average: $37.35. As
with gold, we expect heightened price volatility for silver in 2012 –
but more so, with investors seeing silver as a leveraged play on gold.
This in part reflects heightened political and economic uncertainty
which plays havoc with the commodities markets. We expect to see silver
holding robust interest amongst the speculator community and gaining in
respect amongst the investor community with a tightening market
justifying prices well above the $20 level.
However, slower global industrial output coupled with a firm US dollar in H1 2012 should provide a drag on runaway silver prices – although we see the possibility of a brief price spike based around difficult geopolitical concerns. Should economic conditions prove less difficult than feared in H2, then there are grounds for saying that silver could benefit as a recovery stock of sorts based upon its good industrial applications. So for silver its a case of heads or tails / we win really.